Are you looking for the best pizza in New Braunfels? Well, I’ve got you covered!
New Braunfels may be a German town but we can definitely hold our own when it comes to a great Pizza Pie!
Of course, we have the typical Pizza Hut, Dominoes, and Mod Pizza, but if you are a true pizza lover, then I know you want something a little more than the typical big chain pizzas. And the New Braunfels’ local pizza joints deliver in a big way.
This post is all about the Best Pizza in New Braunfels.
The Best Pizza in New Braunfels:
Inferno’s Wood-Fired Oven and Spirits:
1198 Gruene RD
My Recommendation: Pizza with basil pesto sauce, chicken, bacon, and extra cheese.
Check the calendar for their live music schedule.
Gluten-Free Options Available
Infernos has been serving wood-fired pies in Gurene since 2013 and was voted Best in New Braunfels 2018.
They are a family-friendly pizzeria, offering a wide selection of delicious appetizers, salads, and sandwiches. But they are best known for their Wood-Fired Artisan-Style Pizzas and Stromboli.
Whether you are looking for the classic favorite Margherita Pizza or are feeling brave enough for their Infernos Scorpion Pepper Pizza, they will definitely have something for everyone.
This is one of my favorite places to meet a friend for a nice lunch. If the weather is nice you can enjoy your meal on their patio.
Check the calendar for their live music schedule. Gluten-Free Options Available
Above Ground Pizza
Above Ground Pizza in New Braunfels is a charming, family-owned pizzeria that serves up delicious, hand-tossed pizzas. The menu includes a wide variety of classic and unique toppings, including options such as a creamy wild mushroom pie, a pesto pie with artichoke hearts, and Kalamata olives. And we can’t forget the meat lover’s favorite. Codie’s Primal Pie features meatballs, hot Italian sausage, sliced ham, pepperoni, and roasted green chili topped with a 5 cheese blend.
Keto Options – Crustless Pizza Bowl and Take and Bake! Pizzas to go!
Don’t forget to order a Giant Bavarian Pretzel. You can’t visit New Braunfels without eating at least one.
See Also: The Best Coffee Shops in New Braunfels
New York Pizza Pub
2345 SH-337 Loop
If you’re looking for a pizza place with a New York vibe, then this is it.
New York Pizza Pub in New Braunfels tx is a casual, family-friendly pizzeria that serves up delicious, authentic New York-style pies. The menu features classic favorites like pepperoni and sausage as well as more unique options like sliced meatballs.
Not only do they offer delicious pizza, but they also offer a large selection of homemade Italian favorites like baked ziti, baked lasagna, calzone, and more.
The restaurant is cozy and inviting, with rustic decor that makes you feel like you’ve just stepped into a traditional New York pizzeria.
Confession time!! When we make our pizza at home on our Ooni, this is where I go to get my pizza dough! It always cooks up perfectly giving us solid pies every time.
Bootleggers Pizza Parlor
197 S Seguine Ave
Pizza, Cocktails, Beer, and Billiards, Oh MY! This is no ordinary pizza joint. They do have everyone’s favorite build-your-own pizza with an array of delicious sauces and toppings to choose from. But they also offer some incredible specialty pizzas. Do you want pot roast on your pizza? Do you want fried chicken on your pizza? This is the place for you.
Bootleggers boast a comfortable and approachable atmosphere making it perfect for a casual night out with family and friends.
The prices are affordable and the menu is extensive featuring appetizers, pasta, and salad, as well as their signature pizza. They also have an impressive cocktail menu and 22 draft beers, so you will surely find something for everyone.
Whether you want a slice of cheese pizza or are feeling a little more adventurous and ready to try something truly unique, Bootleggers is a great choice.
They also have a fabulous happy hour Monday thru Friday 3:00-6:00.
See Also: Best New Braunfels Area Wineries
2637 SH-337 Loop
Bosses Pizza in New Braunfels is the perfect choice for a night out with family and friends. They offer a wide variety of delicious food options including, specialty pizzas, mouthwatering wings, and the best burgers.
They also have a party room to accommodate larger groups and special occasions. With ice-cold beer and retro video games, this pizza spot is sure to be a hit with everyone.
See Also: The Best Shopping in New Braunfels
Marcos Pizza – 830-302-4850 – 2084 Central Plz, Ste 101
1860 S Walton Ave
Whether you’re looking for a quick bite on the go or want to hang with friends and family you can always count on Marco’s Pizza to have what you need. They offer original crust, thin and crispy, as well as cauliflower crust.
Their original sauce is fantastic but their white sauce deserves some love too. They have several pizzas featuring this delicious sauce.
If you’re looking for something besides pizza, Marcos offers an amazing menu of Specialty pizza bowls, subs, salads, and wings.
And don’t forget the star of the show, DESSERT. They have Cinnasquares, an ooey gooey buttery pastry topped with cinnamon and sugar. Or if you’re a chocolate lover you can get one of their decadent brownies made with Ghirardelli chocolate and topped with a drizzle of more chocolate.
What to order? Crispy thin crust all meat pizza and of course, an order of Cinnasquares.
Contact free delivery and carryout available
NB’s Wicked Bah Pizza
111 S Union Ave
NB’s Wicked Bah Pizza is located in the heart of New Braunfels’ summer hustle and bustle, the middle of both Schlitterbahn parks. So, you are sure to be in the area at some point during your stay so why not stop in and grab a pie?
With starters like buffalo chicken eggrolls and wicked cheesy garlic bread, you know the rest of the menu will not disappoint.
All of their pizzas are 10 inches and made to order using only the freshest ingredients. They make their dough by hand, in-house daily so you know you are getting a great pie.
Along with a vast array of toppings, you can also choose to have your pizza drizzled with their house-made hot honey. This simple addition will elevate your pizza to the next level.
At the time of publishing this article, Nb’s Wicked Bah Pizza does not serve alcohol. But you can bring your own and that’s a great way to keep costs down when you need your pizza fix.
1850 SH-46 W
From Build Your Own Pizza to Specialty Pizzas, like the Billy Goat and Chicken Bacon Ranch Stouts pizza has something that is sure to hit the spot. They even have a Greek Pizza featuring kalamata olives, artichoke hearts, and Feta cheese.
If you’re craving something other than pizza, they also offer numerous salad and calzone options.
Choose one of their pepperoni rolls or bread sticks to get you started and then finish up with one of their delicious pizzas. Now that’s a meal everyone can get excited about.
Di’s Homemade Pizza
211 W Lincoln St
Delivery available – They do not do online orders, you must go in to order
Di’s Homemade Pizza has been serving pies to New Braunfels for 11 years. They only sell one size pizza and that’s EXTRA LARGE. Who doesn’t love a 16” pizza?
At $19.99 Di’s Supreme is loaded with toppings like pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, black olives, onions, and green peppers. They also offer a meat lover and Vegetarian option as well as the always controversial pineapple and ham pizza.
A one-topping pizza is $14.99 with $2 for each additional topping. Salads and wings are also offered. So, next time you get a craving for a pizza, head to Di’s for an authentic homemade pie.
Wicked Good Pizza
If you’re in the Canyon Lake area you definitely want to stop into Wicked Good Pizza. They have two locations to serve you, one in Sattler and another in Startzville.
In addition to their create-your-own-pizza option, they also offer a Philly cheese steak pizza, a buffalo chicken ranch pizza, and a blt option
This Post was all about the Best Pizza in New Braunfels.
From pies smothered in alfredo sauce and pesto to wood-fired stromboli, New Braunfels has some of the best pizzas in the Lone Star State. So next time your pizza craving strikes, be sure to give one of these pizza places a try. You won’t be disappointed.
You may also like: